Story, Indiana Wine Festival - April 2007

Submitted by Rita Chapman of Indianapolis, Indiana

Attending Indiana wine festivals is truly an adventure in navigation and sensory perception.  Upon leaving Columbus, Indiana, which is named for Christopher Columbus, we were truly ready to "discover" the wines of Indiana.
     The first town encountered was Stony Lonesome, appropriately named!  After a few minutes, the town of Gnawbone is reached. Gnawbone is known as the "flea market capital of the world" as it boasts one flea market for every five residents.  One flea market was visited for a very short time; however, no empty wine bottles, drunks  or wine accessories were found.  There is much debate over the name "Gnawbone!"  One tale states it was initially named after a French town, Narbonne.  However, by the time it was translated by Hoosiers it was called Gnaw Bone.  Another tale says it was named for a drunk who got lost on the way home.  Nevertheless, we are on our way to Story, Indiana.
     Story, Indiana is a tiny, tiny hamlet settled in the heart of Brown County amidst log homes, a few bed and breakfasts and a dude ranch.  Indiana history claims it was named for one of its first settlers, Dr. George  P. Story. However, Indiana folklore claims another "story." A general store was utilized by men in the 1800's to sit and tell stories, mainly lies!  The Great Depression hit Story very hard and the remaining residents made a living bootlegging gin.
     The town remained a shell of its past until the general store was sold at auction in 1998.  The vision was to convert the general store into an inn.  The well-preserved Standard Oil gas pumps still standing in front of the old general store are a delight to artisans and travelers alike.  The first floor of the restaurant is a renowned restaurant with many politicians frequenting the place.  Maybe, "lies" are still told at the Story Inn!
     The cellar of the Story Inn has been converted into the Story Still, where villagers and Brown County residents share camaraderie.  The Story Still's claim to fame is its on-going village idiot contests.  Patrons of the tavern nominate any individual with a unique story. "Reigning Idiots" get a $100.00 credit at the bar and a certificate hung on the wall.
     I am very surprised that no Indiana wines have been named after the Blue Lady of Story that supposedly haunts diners and bed and breakfast guests.  Guests at the Inn are provided journals to describe visits by the Blue Lady and many "sightings" have been recorded. 
     Now, we proceed to the real "story", a day at the annual Story, Indiana Wine Fair.  Admission to the fair doubled this year to $10.00 which included a commemorative glass.  This truly did not stop oenophiles from navigating country roads and paying $3.00 a gallon for gas to attend since a record number of 3,000 were present!  I knew we were in for a treat as shuttle buses transported guests from an upscale artisan inn, a golf resort, an abbey inn (the monks were maybe making wine) to a dude ranch.  The diversity of the guests' lodging truly segued into the varied offerings of Indiana wines.
     The Wine Fair seemed much bigger this year due to the fact that three tents of wineries were offered.  A brief map listing Indiana award winning wines and location of the wineries was presented.  An idea would be to place wineries by locale or by wine trail in close proximity.  Many of the Indiana wineries are small and their town and wine trail affiliation could be placed under their winery name sign.  This would be beneficial to novice oenophiles and out of state travelers.
     A great band played Allman Brothers and other southern rock tunes with a hint of bluegrass.  One complaint is some tasters were in no haste to taste.  The "parking violation" of being towed to another winery or picnic spot should be imposed after five minutes.
     Food seemed to be more abundant this year; however, bread/cheese/fruit offerings could be positioned closer to the wine tents.   Local farmers could also be invited to sell their wares as Brown County boasts many acres of produce.  A few artisans participated showing jewelry and pottery but did not seem to be very busy.  A vacation timeshare company was also present and since my husband and I already own two, I did not go near them!
     Since this article commenced with some Indiana folklore, Indiana wines with unusual names will be explored!
     Buck Creek Winery offers a semi-sweet red wine called Bally Hoo.
     The upscale Carousel Winery offers White Dove White which is a blend.  Carousel Winery also has a red wine called Red Tiger Red that teases the senses.
     Chateau Thomas Winery, one of the larger and most well-known Indiana wineries boasts two reds with "descriptive names."  Chateau Thomas does possess great wines; however, they grow no grapes in Indiana.  Many states have laws that require wineries to grow a percentage of their grapes in the same state.  Indiana, unfortunately does not. This is a question that wine aficionados should ask when visiting wineries.  By supporting the estate wineries where grapes are grown and wine is produced on-site, you will learn more and benefit the upcoming winery. "Boldly Red" is a robust wine that is named for a thoroughbred horse, Boldly Gifted!  This wine is "tempered" by enjoying it with meats and cheeses. "Chateau Big Red," is definitized as a "Big Red for a 'Knight' to Remember."  Did they really mean a 'night to remember' for wine goers who sipped one too many!!
     Ferrin's Fruit Winery was a favorite of many!  I really do not enjoy fruit wines unless they are very dry.  However, all palates should be respected as favorites do vary from person to person. I award this winery the winner "sips down" for the most imaginative and intriguing names. "Checkered Flag," is a semi-sweet grape based Chocolate flavored wine named for racing...This wine proved to be one of the most talked about. "Taste of Love," is a light, sweet Strawberry wine.  Enough said there! "Plum Desirable," is a sweet, sweet plum wine with a residual sugar content of 10%.  I personally do not find this wine to be "desirable," and settled for a 'tease' of "Sweet Caress," which is a semi-sweet pear wine. A sweet red wine titled, "Vineyard Passion," was also offered.  My husband has a small vineyard in our backyard with an adjacent hot tub!   Ferrin's  even offers a type of 'sinner's  wine,' called "Eve's Forbidden Fruit," which is a very sweet (8% residual sugar) apple wine.
     Carmel, Indiana's Grape Inspirations Winery has a wine called "Red Thunder," which is a full-bodied red wine with hints of fruits, spice, vanilla, plum and raisin.
     One of the few Indiana estate wineries, Madison Vineyards, offers Ba-Da-Bing which is patterned after the wines of northwest Italy.  They offer this wine as a red and white wine.  I sampled the white Ba-Da-Bing and was delighted!
     One of the few Indiana wineries to name wines with an Indiana identity is Oliver Winery.  Beanblossom Blush and Beanblossom Hard Cider are named after the small town of Beanblossom, Indiana.  Simmons Winery named Nortonburg Red after the small town of Nortonburg, which is near their winery.
     One of the wine names I personally found humorous was Thomas Family Winery's, "Sack" which is a sherry wine.  Sherries are considered dessert wines.  Did they really mean for us to "hit the sack" after drinking this?
     On a personal note, my husband has named his Pleasant Run Red after a creek that flows through parts of  Indianapolis, Indiana.  This wine has been entered into the Indiana Wine competition at the State Fair.  However, my husband has won awards for his Chambourcin, De Chaunac and Dry Cherry.
     Upon leaving Story, Indiana, a sign for the town of Needmore was spotted.  Most wine goers left this festival without "needing more".

Rita Chapman is a frequent visitor to the Winery Adventures website and attended the 2007 Indiana Wine Fair.